Because they demonstrate to you the same feelings I come away with from all of my engagement with Henry Abbott, that he is simply incapable of following the thought process of a conversation from moment-to-moment.
He comes into the interview with a clear agenda, even though it doesn’t seem like he’s really read the book or come away from it with any interesting questions. Meanwhile Scott Raab calls him directly on a number of points and veiled insults, most of which Henry either dodges or backs away from.
Or he picks some strange little wrinkle to argue about, such as when Raab responds to a question saying “millions of sports fans feel this way” and Abbott, to absolutely no rhetorical advantage whatsoever, says “we’re not talking about sports fans, we’re talking about you” which is equivalent to saying “nanny nanny boo boo sloan institute”.
But I’ll leave the most concise critique of Henry Abbott and TrueHoop to Raab himself:
This insistence that you somehow have hold of some truth that I’m just blind to is just lunacy.
A perfect summary of Henry Abbott’s particular blend of arrogance and ignorance.
(I actually forgot about Raab’s book until this series, so thanks to Henry for the pointer, as I purchased the ebook version to play on my Newton. The book itself very clearly declares its agenda in the title (The Whore of Akron), is very clearly set up as one man’s dystopian walk through fantasia and schadenfreude, and not some journalistic, objective enterprise. It’s a fun read if you hate LeBron and love handjobs.)